top of page

Food Defense Plan vs Food Fraud Vulnerability Assessment

Nov 2
6 min read

Updated: Nov 10

Reviewed by Aaron Lyon, President of A.P. Lyon and former Director of Quality Assurance and International Regulatory, with more than 30 years in medical device quality. Last reviewed November 10, 2026.


Food defense and food fraud both deal with someone deliberately putting something wrong into your product. That shared idea is why many sites file them in one document. The motive is different, the questions you ask are different, and the rules that apply are different. This post explains what each document is for, what FSSC 22000 Version 7 and FDA expect, and how to keep the two assessments clean and auditable.


The short version


  • Food defense protects against intentional adulteration meant to cause harm, whether by an outsider or an insider. The core outputs are a food defense threat (or vulnerability) assessment and a food defense plan.

  • Food fraud protects against deliberate deception for economic gain, such as substitution, dilution or misrepresentation of an ingredient or product. The core outputs are a food fraud vulnerability assessment and a food fraud mitigation plan.

  • Both feed the same food safety management system, but they look at different points in your operation and usually draw on different people.


What FSSC 22000 Version 7 requires


FSSC 22000 Version 7 was published in May 2026. In Part 2 of the scheme, the additional requirements keep food defense at clause 2.5.3 and food fraud mitigation at clause 2.5.4.


Both clauses now open with a competence requirement. Clause 2.5.3(a) requires the organization to "ensure that the food defense threat assessment and food defense plan are developed and maintained by personnel having the appropriate knowledge and competence." Clause 2.5.4(a) uses the same wording for the food fraud vulnerability assessment and food fraud mitigation plan.


FSSC has also said that the detailed food defense and food fraud text in the scheme was reduced because the new prerequisite program standard, ISO 22002-100:2025, now carries much of it. Read the FSSC clauses and ISO 22002-100 together, and keep records that show who built each assessment and why they were qualified.


On timing, FSSC allows Version 6 audits up to 30 April 2027. Upgrade audits to Version 7 run from 1 May 2027 to 30 April 2028.


What FDA requires for food defense: 21 CFR Part 121


In the United States, food defense is covered by the intentional adulteration rule, 21 CFR Part 121, not by the preventive controls rule in Part 117. Key requirements include:


  • A written food defense plan (121.126) that includes the vulnerability assessment, mitigation strategies, and written procedures for food defense monitoring, corrective actions and verification.

  • A written vulnerability assessment (121.130) for each type of food, evaluating each point, step or procedure against three elements: the potential public health impact if a contaminant were added, the degree of physical access to the product, and the ability of an attacker to successfully contaminate the product. The assessment must consider the possibility of an inside attacker, and it must explain why each step was or was not identified as an actionable process step.

  • Written mitigation strategies (121.135) at each actionable process step, with an explanation of how each strategy significantly minimizes or prevents the vulnerability.

  • Reanalysis (121.157) of the plan as a whole at least once every 3 years, and sooner after a significant change, new information about vulnerabilities, or a finding that a mitigation strategy is not properly implemented.

  • Training (121.4). People assigned to actionable process steps, and their supervisors, must receive food defense awareness training, and the training must be documented with the date, type of training and persons trained.


Part 121 has exemptions. Under 121.5 it does not apply to a very small business as defined in 121.3 (which must still keep documentation showing it qualifies), to the holding of food except in liquid storage tanks, or to packing and labeling where the container that directly contacts the food remains intact. Check the definitions in 121.3 against your own facility before deciding you are exempt.


Where food fraud sits in FDA rules


FDA does not have a separate food fraud rule. Instead, the hazard analysis in 21 CFR 117.130(b)(2)(iii) requires you to consider known or reasonably foreseeable hazards that "may be intentionally introduced for purposes of economic gain." That means economically motivated adulteration that creates a food safety hazard belongs in your Part 117 hazard analysis and, where needed, your preventive controls.


For an FSSC 22000 site in the U.S., the FSSC food fraud vulnerability assessment looks broadly at fraud risk across materials and suppliers. Any fraud scenario that could create a food safety hazard is then carried into the hazard analysis under Part 117.


How the two assessments differ in practice


The question each one asks


  • Food defense: Where could someone deliberately contaminate our product to cause harm, and how easy would it be?

  • Food fraud: Which materials or products are attractive targets for substitution or misrepresentation, and how would we know?


Where each one looks


  • Food defense looks inside the facility: process steps, access to open product, mixing and holding points, liquid storage, and who can reach them.

  • Food fraud looks mostly upstream: raw materials, ingredients, packaging, supplier history, price pressure and how easy it is to detect substitution.


Who usually contributes


  • Food defense draws on operations, maintenance, security and human resources, because physical access and insider risk are central.

  • Food fraud draws on purchasing, supplier quality and the laboratory, because supply chain and testing information are central.


Typical controls


  • Food defense: access restrictions, locks and seals, two-person rules at sensitive steps, monitoring of actionable process steps.

  • Food fraud: supplier approval and verification, specifications, certificates of analysis backed by testing, and changes in supplier or source triggering a fresh review.


Gaps to check before your audit


  • One combined document. A single "food defense and fraud" form often answers neither question well. Keep separate assessments, even if they share a procedure.

  • No inside attacker. Part 121 requires it, and it is a sensible check for any FSSC 22000 food defense assessment.

  • No explanation for excluded steps. Part 121 requires a written reason for each step that was or was not identified as actionable.

  • No competence evidence. Under Version 7 clauses 2.5.3(a) and 2.5.4(a), be ready to show who developed each assessment and plan and why they were competent.

  • Stale reviews. Reanalyze after significant changes to process, layout, suppliers or materials, and keep a record of the review and its outcome.

  • Fraud findings that stop at the assessment. Link fraud risks to supplier approval, specifications and testing.


How A.P. Lyon documents fit


A.P. Lyon documents are editable Word and Excel files that work in a paper-based system or can be imported into an eQMS. The food safety documents most relevant to this topic are:


  • Food Defense Procedure (SOP 8-028-F), written to FDA 21 CFR 121 and the FSSC 22000 food defense requirement, with forms for the threat assessment, for monitoring, corrective action and verification, and for plan approval and reanalysis.

  • Food Fraud Vulnerability Assessment Procedure (SOP 8-029-F), with a combined food fraud vulnerability assessment and mitigation plan form.

  • Supplier Approval and Control Procedure (SOP 8-040-F), with a supplier questionnaire, approved supplier list and supplier verification and performance review record, where many fraud mitigation measures are applied.

  • Food Safety Management System — Complete, which includes all three procedures with the manual, the Food Safety Plan and HACCP Workbook, and the other procedures and forms.


Each document needs to be adapted to your site, products and markets, and reviewed by a qualified person before use.


Next steps


Browse the full Food Safety Management System category, or use Build Your QMS to pick only the procedures you need: 20% off 5–9 procedures, 35% off 10–19, 50% off 20–39 and 60% off 40 or more. If you want help adapting documents to your system or setting them up in an eQMS, see A.P. Lyon consulting.



Not sure where your quality system stands? Take the free QMS gap check: about 20 questions, an instant report of your gaps by clause, and the procedures that close each one.


Just getting started? The free Startup Quality Plan shows which procedures you need now, which can wait, and how long they take to put in place.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page